Friday, March 30, 2012

How to write a linguistics essay

This week I'm busy marking first-year essays which asked the students to discuss the context and purpose of a set text with reference to the linguistic and graphic features of the text in 500 words (just a short one as a diagnostic assessment early in the semester). I have about 100 of them to mark in total and as usual I'm finding myself writing the same kind of feedback on most of them.

This genre of essay is often a tricky one for first-year students to figure out, because they don't have to do any extra reading and they haven't learnt much in the way of tools or technical terms by the end of week 3 when the assignment is due. It requires working out what they think the context and purpose of the text is and then making an argument based on the decision they make. It also involves working out what features of the text can be pointed to as evidence for their judgement about its context and purpose. On top of that, they need to be able to organise their ideas into a coherent essay using appropriate academic expression.

There are a few recurrent issues that I keep having to address in my feedback, and so I thought I'd make a list of tips responding to them. Perhaps future linguistics students might be able to benefit from this - essay-writing advice is usually too general to be able to help work out what an analytical linguistics essay requires.
  • Work out what your answer to the question is in general terms. This will form the basis of your introduction and help you make a plan for the rest of your essay. For example, if the text is a book review and you think the context and purpose of the text is to summarise and evaluate the book and recommend it to readers from the academic community in the discipline of Russian history, your introduction might say something like "The book review of [book name] by [reviewer] is written with the purpose of providing a summary and evaluation of the book's contents and recommending the book to readers, in particular Russian history scholars." In one sentence, you have introduced the text and answered the question about the purpose of the text as well as its intended audience.
  • Identify the features of the text that help you understand that the purpose of the text is to summarise, evaluate and recommend the book and that the intended readers are Russian history scholars. For example, there might be a paragraph of the text giving a chapter-by-chapter outline of the book; there might be lots of summarising, comparing & contrasting or evaluative language; and there might be lots of positive evaluations of the book, especially at the end of the text. Pick out one or two brief phrases from each of these features that would support your claim most strongly.
  • Summarise the features you have identified in a general way so that you can include a brief and general indication of them in your introduction. This will be a signal to your reader of the points that you will cover in your essay. For example, you could follow the introductory sentence in point 1 above with something like this: "These contextual features of the text are evident from the linguistic choices such as summarisation, comparison, and evaluation."
  • Your essay should always move from the general to the specific. The introduction should give a general overview of your argument and the points you'll make (as demonstrated above) and therefore should not include any specific examples or evidence. Save that for the body of your essay where you argue each point. This principle also applies to each paragraph in the body of your text (see below).
  • Write a topic sentence for each paragraph stating a general point about the context and purpose of the text. For the book review example, you might have three paragraphs: one about the summarising and evaluating function of the text, one about the recommending function of the text, and one about the target readers of the text (depending on the specifics of the question asked). Your topic sentences should be linked back to your introduction and should just be observations of the text, e.g. not 'The text contains lots of evaluative words...' but 'The text has a primary function of summarising and evaluating the book. This can be see through the use of a chapter-by-chapter outline in paragraph 2, e.g. 'In chapter 1, the author... In chapter 2'.' I'm using fairly basic expression here just to give an example of the unfolding of meanings required in each paragraph. Start with the general (the main point for that paragraph), and move towards the specific (the examples from the text).

Friday, March 16, 2012

The Language of God

I had some days off sick this week, which gave me the opportunity to do a bit of long-awaited leisure reading. So I started reading 'The Language of God' (2006, Free Press), which I found amongst the small collection of books my husband already owned before I moved in with my several extra bookshelves worth!

I was initially attracted by the title, as you can imagine - but it's not really about 'language' of the kind that I study. It's written by Dr Francis Collins, who is the head of the Human Genome Project, and the title is taken from US President Bill Clinton's speech at the official public launch of the findings of the Human Genome Project, the human DNA sequence, in 2000. Clinton said: "Today we are learning the language in which God created life. We are gaining ever more awe for the complexity, the beauty, and the wonder of God's most divine and sacred gift." (see full transcript here).

Collins' aim in the book is to dispel the notion that a rigorous science precludes serious belief in a transcendent God "by arguing that belief in God can be an entirely rational choice, and that the principles of faith are, in fact, complementary with the principles of science" (p.3). As part of this, he gives his own testimony as a scientist with a firm faith in God.

I haven't finished reading it yet (only up to chapter 3) but I have thoroughly enjoyed reading the first two chapters. In the first chapter, Collins shares the story of his interesting childhood, his growing thirst for scientific knowledge, his studies in chemistry and then medicine, and ultimately, sparked by the simple question of a dying woman, his discovery of a God who is there, and who takes a personal interest in human beings.

He also shares some of the trains of thought he went through during this time of discovery, inspired by the writings of C.S. Lewis, another academic who had taken a very similar path from atheism to faith. These included the perplexing fact that "the concept of right and wrong appears to be universal among all the members of the human species" and that "this law appears to apply peculiarly to human beings" (p.23). I was encouraged and excited to read his reflections on the differences between humans and animals on this point, as this is an issue that has been on my mind, as seen in last week's blog post. I was glad to find some support for my ideas from a more knowledgeable source. It's nice to know I might be thinking on the right track!



Friday, March 9, 2012

Humans and animals

I've been saying in other blog posts that humans are created in God's image (Genesis 1:26-27) and are communicative and relational. But we can also observe communication and relationship in some, if not all, animal species. The Genesis account makes it clear that animals are not created in God's image. So what is the difference between the kind of communication and relationships that humans and animals have? What is it about human communication and relationships that is special and particularly reflects our status as God's image-bearers?
I think it's love. When I think about what we see as relationships between animals, they are really utilitarian, rather than characterised by love. Animals enter into relationships with other animals mainly for procreation (only for very few is this an exclusive relationship) and for cooperation related to food sourcing etc. But the procreating kind of relationship is driven by hormones and instinct rather than love. While hormones and instincts are also involved in human relationships, humans are also able to override their hormones and instincts when necessary for the sake of another person. As far as I know, animals do not have the option of exercising self-control for the sake of another. As far as I know, they do not make choices which sacrifice their own desires for the sake of another, to put the other first. To do that would seem to go against the 'survival of the fittest' principle.
Humans' ability to have loving relationships that display conscious, deliberate self-sacrifice seems to me to be a direct reflection of God's relational character. God's deep love is supremely demonstrated in the way God the Father sent his only Son to die as a sacrifice for the sake of those he loved (see John 3:16 and 1 John 4:9-10), and the way God the Son willingly sacrificed himself for the glory and honour of his Father, because he loved his Father and wanted to obey him (see Luke 22:41-42).

Friday, February 24, 2012

Christian/Muslim debate video link

As promised last year, here's the link to the YouTube video of the debate between James White and Abdullah Kunde that I moderated in October. You'll need to set aside a bit of time to watch it all the way through, but I'm sure you'll find it's a worthwhile thing to watch and listen to.


A new year, a new name

After a long silence on my blog, I feel I'm returning having emerged from a chrysalis in which I've undergone some significant changes. Not so much to my form (I'm far from being a butterfly!) but to many of the circumstances of my life.

I got married almost three weeks ago, so now I have a new name (Mrs/Dr Claire Urbach), a new home and neighbourhood, a new routine, new responsibilities and joys as a wife, and I'll soon start a new semester of teaching while continuing the ministry training I began last semester.

We had a lovely time away on our honeymoon and stayed in some gorgeous spots along the north coast of New South Wales - the sunset photo below was taken from the balcony of our riverfront apartment at Nambucca Heads. If only we could have stayed there longer than one night!

 We were very excited to be able to get a close-up view of koalas in the wild at Port Stephens - not just one koala, but a koala with a baby on its back, descending a tree, walking across the ground, and climbing up another tree! Very cute. I wanted to upload a video here but it didn't seem to work, unfortunately.
 There were also some awesome goannas which we were fortunate to spot - this large one (a lace monitor, I think) at Rocky Creek Dam in the Byron Bay hinterland...
 
 ...and this one up a tree at the top of Mt Yarahappini in the Nambucca Valley region.
Previously my Dutch husband has been (jokingly) convinced that all famous Australian wildlife (kangaroos, etc) do not really exist and if you do see one it'll be either at a zoo or wildlife park, or in the distance in the wild, and is therefore just a person wearing a suit. But I think these sightings of koalas and goannas were sufficient evidence for him at least for the existence of those creatures. The jury is still out on kangaroos, though, until we see one that is not in a wildlife park or dead on the side of the road!

Thursday, December 22, 2011

Christmas legends

I haven't been officially 'working' since semester finished towards the end of October, and I've found that the relative loss of structure in the week has made me much less efficient. The regularity of my blog posts has certainly suffered! But here I am, 3 days before Christmas, determined to make at least one more post before the year is out (actually I have a few more ideas up my sleeve so I might just get another one out before the end of the year!).

I've been doing a lot of carol-singing in the lead-up to Christmas this year, which is rather fun. Last night I sang in the foyer of a local RSL club with the choir I've been singing with for years. After we sang the song 'Little Donkey', I heard one of the tenors objecting that there was no mention of a donkey in Luke's gospel (which is true) but "they were all legends anyway so it doesn't matter". My hackles rose, and at that point I was struck by the combination of songs that we hear around us at Christmas, in every shopping centre and public place. There is such a mingling of truth and fiction that it's no wonder people are confused between legend and history.



From the songs we sang last night, 'Frosty the Snowman', Santa Claus' (at least the concept originating from a Coca Cola campaign of the 30s), 'Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer' - all these are fictitious characters. And yet there are attempts in the lyrics of the songs to lend historical validity to them. 'Rudolph' is sung about in past tense as if the story is being told by an eyewitness: 'Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer had a very shiny nose, and if you ever saw it, you would even say it glows. All of the other reindeer used to laugh and call him names...'. In 'Frosty the Snowman', an attempt is made to downplay they mythical sense of the story, and to invoke children as the true 'knowers': 'Frosty the snowman was a fairytale, they say. He was made of snow, but the children know how he came to life one day'. In 'Santa Claus is Coming to Town'.

Interestingly, all these songs were written in the twentieth century driven by a commercial imperative. The Wikipedia entry for Rudolph the Red-nosed Reindeer has this telling sentence: 'Although the story and song are not public domain, Rudolph has become a figure of Christmas folklore.' The story is 'owned' by a company, 'The Rudolph Company'! 'Frosty the Snowman' was written in 1950 and recorded by the same person who released the first recording of 'Rudolph', who, according to Wikipedia, was "in search of another seasonal hit". Frosty even has a MySpace page, which lists friends such as 'Santa' and 'SNOW', 'where children of all ages from all over the world can write to their favorite snowman' (Wikipedia)! 'Santa Claus is coming to town', after being released in November 1934, "became an instant hit with orders for 100,000 copies of sheet music the next day and more than 400,000 copies sold by Christmas".


Whatever the motivation, these and other Christmas songs (like this incredibly cheesy one I heard a while ago - Here Comes Suzy Snowflake!) have certainly captured the imagination of children in many English-speaking countries. But I worry that as the public imagination is engaged by these clearly fictional songs, the Christmas songs, both old and new, that relate the true story of Jesus (e.g. Hark the Herald Angels Sing, The First Nowell, Silent Night, Holy Lamb of God) are increasingly lumped in with the fictional 'Christmas folklore'.

There may be few historical records beyond the gospel of Luke that record and give evidence of the circumstances of Jesus' birth in Bethlehem. But there are plenty of historical records to substantiate the gospel claims of Jesus' earthly works, his death, and his resurrection (see e.g. historical surveys in Morison's 'Who Moved the Stone?', Dickson's 'The Christ Files'). And by these and the Spirit of God in me, I am convinced that Jesus is the Son of God. I am therefore inclined to believe that what Luke's gospel says about Jesus' birth is more than just legend. A God who can raise someone from the dead can surely make a virgin birth happen. And A God who can do all that and who gave His Son as a gift to all people, none of whom had been 'good', is much more worthy of my attention than a snowman who dissolves when the temperature goes up, a reindeer with a glowing red nose, or an old chubby guy with a beard who gives gifts once a year to children who have been good.

Monday, December 12, 2011

Lots of ex-CITE-ment


Last week I had the pleasure of attending the Cite Jesus conference for the third time (see posts about the previous Cite conferences). Cite is the annual national conference for Christians working in academia (the Simeon Network), whether as lecturers/professors, researchers or postgraduate students. Around 35 academics, researchers and postgraduate students met alongside the 1500 undergraduate students at the AFES National Training Event in Canberra. The Cite delegates came from universities in Sydney, Bathurst, Wollongong, Newcastle, Brisbane, Melbourne, and Canberra. Hopefully next year we'll have people from all the other states and territories, too.

The 5-day Cite conference was focused around 3 strands: Doctrine, Public Christianity and Overseas Mission. In the 'overseas mission' strand, we heard from a number of academics working (or preparing to work) as missionaries in universities around the world. In particular, we heard from three Australian academics - Dr Neville Carr and his wife Elspeth, and Dr Judy Lund - who have been working at St Johns University in Tanzania - a new Christian university, only 4 years old, which was set up by the Anglican church in Tanzania. The Carrs and Dr Lund helped us think through what a 'Christian' university might look like in practice and what our disciplines might look like through a gospel lens.


 They also impressed on us the great needs at the university, operating as it does in a developing country where material resources are scarce (think Internet cable, library books, classrooms, money for field trips), locals with PhDs are extremely rare, and the immediate material needs of the students often mean that attending classes (which is beneficial in the longer term) has to be sacrificed in order to work or harvest or care for family members in rural villages (which is absolutely necessary in the short term). But the need for higher education is great, particularly in teacher education, agriculture and other fields that will help provide for and improve the lives of the Tanzanian people in the longer term. The Carrs and Dr Lund estimate that it could be another 10 years before the university can achieve some stability in terms of staffing, resources and student attendance.

So what can be done? There are some Tanzanian students currently completing doctoral studies overseas with a view to returning to St Johns as academic staff, but this obviously takes time. So there is a great need for foreigners with PhDs to go to Tanzania to teach and help build up the curriculum (see e.g. Malcolm Buchanan and his family who went there with CMS last year). If you don't have a PhD, you could help out by purchasing a length of broadband cable (1m or 5m)! The Tanzanian government is apparently setting up a fibre optic internet backbone for universities around the country, which is great, but the university needs to purchase fibre optic cable to establish a network on campus which can link up to the backbone outside the campus boundaries. Maybe it would make a thoughtful gift for someone you know who is an internet addict!