Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Notes on a haircut

I always enjoy it when I'm in a situation where specialized and everyday discourse come into contact, seeing how the people involved negotiate the interaction so that they can make themselves understood.
For example, a few weeks ago I had a hairdresser appointment (Ed: I actually started writing a blog on it that week but my iPhone went cactus shortly after so I lost all the notes I had made). It was interesting because it was late on a Friday afternoon, just before closing time, and I was the only customer so all 3 staff members were talking to me and discussing my haircut.
In order to explain what I wanted or didn't want done to my hair, I used my own non-technical terms such as 'foof it up' and 'not like a curtain on my head'. They found my attempts to explain hairstyles amusing, but were able to understand what I meant and then used my terms for the rest of the procedure.
In service encounters like hairdressing appointments the domain of experience is quite everyday as far as the customer is concerned - their hair and its appearance. So modifying your use of technical terms when operating at the interface between experts and laypeople is a really useful thing to do.

Saturday, July 24, 2010

Love like this

There is a passage from the Bible that is frequently used at weddings – anyone who has been to a church wedding is highly likely to have heard it even if they don't normally read the Bible or go to church. It's from Paul's first letter to the Corinthians, and it goes like this:

4Love is patient and kind; love does not envy or boast; it is not arrogant 5or rude. It does not insist on its own way; it is not irritable or resentful; 6it does not rejoice at wrongdoing, but rejoices with the truth. 7Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. (1 Corinthians 13:4-7 ESV)

I was reflecting on the meaning of the passage and it occurred to me that it is an immensely challenging passage. That got me thinking about whether I would want to have it read at my wedding (if the opportunity arises), because I thought it would be a bit like holding a magnifying glass up to your relationship at that most public moment of a declaration and promise of love. It's saying 'this is what love is (or should be) – can you do that?'. But I wonder if people just like the sound of it and feel as if that kind of love is 'the way things are', or that it will happen magically once they are pronounced husband and wife.

How many people could actually say that in their relationships (especially with their spouses/partners) they are always patient and kind, never envious or boastful, arrogant or rude? How many people could say they never insist on getting their own way, or are never irritable or resentful? Rejoicing in wrongdoing, i.e. pointing out the other's faults or mistakes in a kind of pointscoring competition seems to be a socially acceptable way of conducting a relationship (just look at Hollywood depictions of relationships). The fact that many people separate and get divorced shows that not everyone is able to bear, believe, hope and endure all things.

The title of this blog is intended in its clausal sense, as imperative mood 'Love like this!' rather than in its phrasal sense '(a) love [like this] (is...)', and I think that's the tone of the passage too: not merely a description of love, but an exhortation to love like this, with Jesus Christ as the perfect example of love like this.


Saturday, June 26, 2010

Moving, just keep moving

It's been a very long time between blogs! I have struggled to keep up with the pace of my new job and so have been a bit snowed under with lecture preparation and marking. Now semester has finished and there's just a bit of collating to do for final grades.

I'm also moving again this week. I have really enjoyed living in the current place but it's great to have the opportunity to move in with a new friend and be able to save a bit on rent. Thankfully some of my things are still in boxes from before (since my current place is furnished) so it's just a matter of moving the boxes as they are. As well as packing up my things here, I have also recently been going through the nostalgic process of packing up and clearing out the family home I lived in for 22 years. There were a lot of memories to sort through and it was sometimes hard to decide what is worth keeping and what is not. I think I have become better at throwing things out (I have always been a hoarder!), and as I have cleared out and thrown out and packed things away, I have found myself thinking about what's really necessary and what is extraneous or unhelpful. Vague thoughts of future overseas work also enter my head and make me wonder what I would take with me.

I want to be able to live simply wherever I am, unencumbered by extra, unnecessary possessions (and not obsessed with accumulating them), but somehow I still find it hard to part with nick-nacks that each have a story to tell – the framed photos of friends and family, the miniature painted china houses my aunt brought me back from Greece, the sequined beanie frog prince that was a gift from a girlfriend for my 16th birthday. And all those books...

Jesus constantly challenged his followers to exchange their treasures on earth for treasures in heaven (Luke 12:33 and Matt 19:21) and to be on their guard against seeing their value in their possessions (Luke 12:15) and it seems that members of the early church were characterised by their willingness to sell their possessions and give to those in need (Acts 2:45). Earlier, the writer of Ecclesiastes pondered a similar question, e.g. Ecclesiastes 5:11 (see Ecclesiates 5:8-20 for more on this theme):

11 As goods increase,
so do those who consume them.
And what benefit are they to the owner
except to feast his eyes on them?

I think his conclusion in 5:19 is helpful in thinking about having balance between the enjoyment of possessions with contentment, and the recognition of where they come from (and hence that they can be taken away at any time) and the fact that they are not really necessary to life and unfulfilling in themselves:

19 Moreover, when God gives any man wealth and possessions, and enables him to enjoy them, to accept his lot and be happy in his work—this is a gift of God.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Mijn hovercraft zit vol palingen (My hovercraft is full of eels)

I was investigating some Dutch language information websites this evening, and I came across this rather interesting one, Omniglot, which among other things provides some 'useful Dutch phrases'. The phrase 'my hovercraft is full of eels' was given in this list. It made me wonder (with tongue firmly in cheek) what kind of a place the Netherlands must be if that is a useful phrase. Certainly hovercrafts must be fairly common, and eels plentiful in the places where hovercrafts are used. And it must be the sort of place where you could say this to someone and they would be filled with sympathy. And perhaps there is also some well-known traditional Dutch method of ridding hovercrafts and other vessels from the slimy creatures which the addressee would immediately set to work to effect, to help you rid your hovercraft of eels. Well, at least I know I'll be well prepared for that contingency next time I visit the Netherlands!

Monday, March 29, 2010

Learning from the source

This week I have been lecturing on using evidence in academic writing – using sources, referencing, quoting, paraphrasing, etc – and how it's not good enough just to quote someone second hand. You actually need to go back to the original source and see that the middle man has conveyed the meaning of the source text accurately. Otherwise it's like Chinese whispers and you never know what convoluted rubbish you could end up with!

I was reminded of Paul's exhortation to Timothy (2 Tim 2:2) to entrust the gospel of Christ to reliable men who would be able to continue to faithfully teach others – passing the baton on, but ensuring it's always the same baton and doesn't get switched for something else in the middle of the race. We need to keep going back to the source – the Word of God, the gospel of Jesus Christ – so that we never just assume we know what it's about and then pass on a twisted or faulty message.

Around the same time I heard that message from 2 Timothy (preached by the faithful Richard Chin at St Michaels Wollongong), I read Amos 2:4-5, where God pronounces judgement on Judah because they have forgotten God's law and have been led astray by their lies, which presumably have resulted from just that same problem – the Word of God was no longer being taught faithfully, people weren't going back to the source but were hearing distortions and allowing them to continue.

So Paul exhorted Timothy to 'preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching (2 Tim 4:2). And we need to always go back to the source to test what we hear or read against the original source.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

“Sainting” and “sanctifying”

I saw a 'news' segment on Mary McKillop a few days ago. They were talking about some letters that Mary McKillop had written during her life, and it was apparently newsworthy that the letters revealed how human she was. Well, she was human, after all. The fact that she is to be declared a saint later this year means precisely that she was human, otherwise there would be no need for her to be sainted. I find the whole 'sainting' (canonisation) thing quite strange. According to the Online Etymology Dictionary, the noun 'saint' derives from the Latin sanctus, meaning 'holy'. Sanctus itself is derived from the verb, sancire, meaning 'to consecrate'. The related English verb, sanctify, derives from the Latin santificare (holy + make), meaning 'to make holy/righteous/pure'. The Dictionary also tells us that the usage of 'saint' as a verb, meaning "to enroll (someone) among the saints", dates only from the late 14th century.

Those who are called saints in the Bible don't do anything particularly special – no miracles supposedly performed by them after death – but are simply Christians, who have heard, understood and been changed by the gospel of Jesus Christ. They become saints not through a process of 'sainting', decided by humans based on what they are supposed to have done after they died, but by a process of sanctification by God while they are still alive. Once they have died it's too late. Furthermore, sanctification is not based on what people do, but based on God's mercy and their faith in His promises to make them righteous.

When Jesus prayed to God before his crucifixion, he said "Sanctify them [the ones whom God had chosen] in the truth; your word is truth... for their sake I consecrate myself, that they may also be sanctified in truth" (John 17: 17, 19). Sanctification gives new life to those who turn from sin to serve God, as Paul says in the first letter to the Corinthians, "Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God?... But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God." (1 Cor 6: 9, 11). And the writer to the Hebrews tells them (us) that it is by the will of God that "we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all" (Hebrews 10: 10). So Christians are already saints in life, and will continue to be saints for eternity!



Some 'saints' I know.

Saturday, March 6, 2010

A linguistic approach to history

To the historian equipped with the proper tools, it is suggested, any text or artefact can figure forth the thought-world and possibly even the world of emotional investment and praxis of its time and place of production. Not that any given text can alone call up the whole world of its origin or that any given set of texts can reveal its world completely. But in principle, it seems to hold that we today possess the tools to probe texts in ways only dimly perceived or, if perceived, not fully utilized by earlier intellectual or other historians. And these tools, it is suggested, are generally linguistic in nature. (White, 1987:187)

The above quotation is taken from the work of a scholar not of linguistics, but of historiography and intellectual history. It is from Hayden White's The Context in the Text: Method and Ideology in Intellectual History. The potential of a text or artefact to 'figure forth the thought-world... of its time and place of production' (White, 1987:187) is a point of departure that is common to both historians and linguists. White is sympathetic to the ideas of linguistics and discourse analysis, advocating a 'semiological' approach to text as the most productive approach to questions concerned with meaning production and the meaning systems by which the meanings in a text are produced.

'Semiological', in White's sense, means 'the tradition of cultural analysis that builds upon the theory of language as a sign (rather than a word) system, after the manner of Saussure, Jakobsson, and Benveniste' (White, 1987:191). One of the schools of linguistics that has developed out of the theories of Saussure and Jakobson, among others, is systemic functional linguistics (SFL). It provides considerable explanatory power for the whole range of linguistic phenomena, from intonation in speech (at the level of phonology) to syndromes of meaning (at the level of semantics) and beyond to the patterns of cultural tendencies. What I have argued in my recent work from my PhD research is that indeed we do have 'the tools to probe texts' to reveal how they 'figure forth the thought-world' of their time and place of production, and that the tools and concepts offered by SFL are ideal for this kind of job.

I'm hoping to post here, over the next little while, some of my thoughts on how linguistic tools can be used in historical enquiry, and particularly the study of media history.

References:

White, H. (1987). The Context in the Text: Method and Ideology in Intellectual History. In The Content of the Form: Narrative Discourse and Historical Representation, 185--213. Baltimore & London: The John Hopkins University Press.